Thursday, April 29, 2010

Illegal Immigration in Arizona: why is Obama not giving Arizona a break?

I always find it easier to picture states or nations in terms of neighborhoods or homes. It’s a little more familiar and concrete that way. Imagine that you live in a well-ordered, policed town, and in order to fund the town, the rightful citizens are taxed. So far, so good. To keep the town in working order, you have to have documentation that you’re a citizen. Makes sense: since if you’re not documented, you can find a way out of getting taxed. That way, you get all the benefits of being in our town, but none of the cost.

This is what is happening in Arizona. Arizona is a border state: in other words, it is a town that borders a foreign neighborhood that aren’t citizens of Arizona. Every day, more and more citizens from Mexico pour over into Arizona, breaking state and federal immigration laws. But this is a problem. Remember: to keep the state fiscally afloat, its citizens need to be taxed. But if you’re in Arizona illegally, you can easily evade taxes. Now, watch what happens.

Mexicans take advantage of the hospitals, the schools, and tax-funded prisons. But what happens if more and more Mexicans come in, use the schools, the hospitals, and fill the prisons, but don’t pay taxes? The state eventually becomes broke. How else are all these services and benefits going to be funded?

As a result, citizens of Arizona are fleeing north, as did the citizens of California.

What is cool is that Arizona governor Jan Brewer had enough. She enforced the immigration laws of her state, because the federal government has been so slow to act while her state is in a fiscal crisis, the same crisis that is making California bankrupt.

But - for some reason that I’m not aware of - Obama doesn’t like what Brewer is doing. Obama called Brewer ‘misguided’. To make the job of Arizona police harder, he has gotten the Justice Department involved to make sure no one’s civil rights are violated. What is frustrating is that we all know what that means. The minute a police officer is suspicious of someone, he’s going to hesitate, because he knows his judgment is under a microscope, and he knows there’s a real possibility that the ACLU could probably prove - in some crooked court - that the ‘undocumented worker’ was racially profiled.

Do you see what’s happening? This is just annoying to me. It seems like Obama can do what he wants - since it is ‘legal’ - but he knows what he is doing. Why not let the Arizona police do their job? Why not give a whole darn state some faith? The federal government isn’t doing anything, and in the mean time, the state is fiscally dying. By doing this, Obama is feeding a theory about him (that isn’t fair at first glance) that’ll make me never vote for him: the majority of Mexicans vote democrat - connect the dots.

So, Obama cares more for the civil rights of people who don’t have a right to be here, and less for the rights of hard-working, legal citizens, who have to go to work everyday, get taxed, and have those taxes pay for the services and benefits of people who evade our laws, who evade taxes, and leech off the system, until the system is dry? I mean, money doesn’t come out of nowhere. It’s got to be taxed. Without taxing hard-working Americans, the Nation’s bank account plummets. I mean, do you guys see the pattern?

Another thing we have a right to do as a Nation is put our military on the border. I think this is called for. Drug cartels come across the border everyday. A lot of times, they’re escorted by the Mexican military - read that again. Hard working farmers have been murdered, along with the police. Kidnappings. Etc. There’s got to be a seal on the border. We can’t just be a nanny forever. It just doesn’t work that way. If you continue to be nice and just let anyone in whenever, we’re not going to last very much longer. It’s just the logic of it, as I see it.

I know the immigration issue is complicated. But seriously. Why is Obama silent on it? There’s 12 to 20 million illegal aliens here. 12 to 20 million! And that’s just roughly. We’re not taking into account all their family connections. No nation in the history of civilization has survived with that track record. Rome did it. Europe is doing it with the muslims.

A part of a nation is its culture. If citizens aren’t naturalized, they bring their culture with them. Multiculturalism is a good thing, and that’s the cool thing about America. We can have a chinatown, a ‘south of the border’, etc. But first and foremost, they’re Americans. A lot of these Mexicans - and you can hear it straight from the horse’s mouth - believe that the southwestern part of America was stolen from them, and that it’s theirs, and they’re going to get it back, not militarily, but from the ground up, from the inside out, coming in, evading the laws, using the voting system, infiltrating American culture, and getting it back, and getting back at us that way.

That’s no way to come to America. That’s a horrible attitude to have. Something has got to be done. And Arizona has taken the initiative. Some statistics show that around 8 million African Americans are being shut off from jobs they’d otherwise have if illegal Mexicans didn’t have them: and Al Sharpton is going to march against Arizona law against the illegals? Oh, the irony.

What is also funny is the irony somewhere else. Mexico has a lot of indignation toward us if we don’t bend over backwards to take in their illegals. But Mexico deports their illegal aliens. Isn’t that hypocritical? And why do they do that? Well, they have immigration laws, and they know they can’t stay fiscally afloat if they have a boatload of illegal citizens who can leech off the services and benefits without being taxed. They know money doesn’t just pop into being out of nothing.

I’ll stop here, but I just thought I’d write this because I think Arizona is doing the right thing, and that Obama is just annoying me.


5 comments:

  1. I agree to a point.

    The whole system needs to readdressed. There is no questioning dollars but there is something to be said about how these officers will be going about it. "Reasonable Suspicion" is not clear enough to help enforce a law, that quite frankly seems racist.

    There is a human element to whole debate that I fear is being pushed under the rug. Again, let me emphasize the fact that I agree with you from a financial level, but as a nation we need to start over when it comes to immigration and take a second look at what is going on. It's hard for me to believe that these "illegals" do not want to become legal.

    From what I understand, to become a citizen it is a long and arduous process that requires money (thats the reason they came here in the first place) and time. Neither of these things come easily to this group.

    I by no means believe I have the answer or assume that it is an easy answer, but I think we need to look at this issue from both sides and remind ourselves that these are people, who the vast majority are trying to support their families.

    We cannot be so cavalier and simply close the door.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yo, yo! I had to chop up my comment because it was too long, lol.

    Yo, yo!

    ****"Reasonable Suspicion" is not clear enough to help enforce a law, that quite frankly seems racist.

    It's more than a reasonable suspicion, though. At the rallies, there are hordes of people shouting out their illegal status like a badge of honor.

    It's hard for me to call it racist for this reason. I agree that not all Mexicans in Arizona are illegal aliens - that is just false: and if the police based their investigations on that, I'd call it racist in a second (if it's not based on fact). So while that's false, I think the converse is true. Namely, while not all Mexicans are illegals; nearly all illegals(supported by statistics) are Mexican, or Latin American. A small, small percentage is South American or Middle Eastern. And it's pretty much due to the fact that Arizona borders Mexico.

    Even in the prisons, they are known to be illegal.

    It's just a matter of deporting them.

    And remember the hypocrisy point I made: if Mexico caught an illegal, he or she is immediately deported.

    It's just a matter of backing the Constitution and the laws of the land. If Obama wants to change that through due process, then he can go ahead. But in the mean time, the law is the law. And Arizona is just following the law: state and federal. For Obama to knock Arizona for doing that is just annoying to me.

    ******It's hard for me to believe that these "illegals" do not want to become legal.

    Well, they want to become legal through amnesty. But what the law demands is that they become legal through the legal process. Because the process needs work, doesn't mean it's all bad, or that it gives them the right to bypass it.

    Statistically, though, the 'amnesty crowd' is under half - but that's still near the 10 million mark, if the 20 million figure is true: or, near the 6 million mark, if the 12 million figure is true. That is a bunch! Too much. They're taking the jobs of the legal Americans who deserve them. And they are the ones making states bankrupt.

    ReplyDelete
  3. ******From what I understand, to become a citizen it is a long and arduous process that requires money (thats the reason they came here in the first place) and time. Neither of these things come easily to this group.

    Very true. Immigration is a beautiful privilege, as is being an American citizen. But the reason why it's beautiful is because of the laws in the first place, the laws that make this country wonderful. If the borders aren't secure, and there isn't an efficient immigration process, the country won't last long at all. Maybe a generation or two.

    ******I by no means believe I have the answer or assume that it is an easy answer, but I think we need to look at this issue from both sides and remind ourselves that these are people, who the vast majority are trying to support their families.

    I do agree with your 'human element' point. It's actually one of the main reasons I wrote the blog. I care for the legal immigrants a whole lot! Their jobs are taken away by the illegals. I want the legals to get the job; and the illegals to wait in line like everyone else. When legions of illegals come over without doing it right, it might be a 'quick fix' for their families, but one by one, they're undermining the whole privilege, and - in the long run - ruining the privilege for everyone a generation or two down the road. As they come over, more and more hospitals will shut down, more and more schools will shut down, the prisons will overflow, and state by state will go bankrupt. It happened in California (which is in a state of fiscal emergency), and it's happening in Arizona (which is why the governor declared a state of emergency for her state).

    ******We cannot be so cavalier and simply close the door.

    I wouldn't close the door by any means. I'd make sure our backdoor is locked and only guests can come in. If I'm in my house and I find out my next door neighbor has hired bodyguards to bypass 'being a guest' in my house in order to sell drugs to other guests in my house, I'd call the police. But this is what Mexico is doing. If you want, I'll give you a link to some stories. The Mexican military is escorting drug cartels across the Mexican-American border! Our National Guard needs to be on that border. That is ridiculous.

    In that sense, the border should be closed just to those people. But the door of legal immigration should be wide open, and those who earn the right to be guests in our house, get to come in and be American citizens.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Police can execute a Terry stop if they have a reasonable, articulable suspicion; this is the standard across the unified states.
    The End

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sympathies are so wasted here. Simply put:

    A man is a city, and a city a country.

    If someone assaults my body, or enters my home uninvited, I shoot to kill, (no matter how much they may need it). Somehow Mexican's have avoided the honest consequence of this metaphor.

    Those who would voluntarily give up life and home for the decrepit should be locked away somewhere dark and cold.

    ReplyDelete